Login
Back to Blog

Bob’s Side Hustle Is Now Your Direct Competitor

You’re sipping your morning coffee, scrolling Instagram, when something familiar catches your eye.

A new account is offering exactly what your company does — same niche, eerily similar language, and even the same stock photo you used on your last campaign.

And then you see it.

It’s Bob.

Your employee.

Running a business on the side that competes directly with yours.

No heads-up. No disclosure. Just a quiet little side hustle… built with everything he learned on your dime.

And the worst part? He didn’t break a single rule — because you never gave him any.

The “But We Never Said He Couldn’t” Problem

This is one of the most common gaps in small business HR: the assumption that if you haven’t approved something, it’s obviously not allowed.

But under Canadian employment law, the opposite is often true.

Unless your contract or policies explicitly prohibit certain behaviours — like working for a competitor, using confidential materials, or running a competing business — employees are generally free to do it. Especially if it’s “on their own time.”

That doesn’t make it ethical. But it does make it legal.

And if you never drew the line? You’ve got no grounds to claim they crossed it.

Why Your Non-Compete Clause Probably Won’t Help

You might be thinking, “Well, we have a non-compete clause in our contracts. That covers this, right?”

Not likely.

In most provinces — especially Ontario and BC — non-competes are extremely difficult to enforce. In Ontario, they’re banned entirely for most employees. Even where they’re legal, courts look at them with suspicion. Unless the clause is specific, narrow in scope, and backed by a legitimate business interest, it’s usually tossed out.

And if you’re using some dusty clause you pulled from a free template site ten years ago? You’ve got nothing.

Bob’s side hustle is probably here to stay.

The Policy You Should Have Had

This is where a real, well-written conflict of interest policy earns its keep.

Unlike vague non-competes, conflict of interest policies actually hold up. They don’t try to prevent someone from working ever again. They simply define the boundaries of what’s acceptable while they work for you.

A good policy makes it crystal clear: you can’t use company knowledge, tools, or time to start something that competes. You can’t take side gigs that put your loyalty in question. And you can’t quietly poach clients from the inside out.

It also gives you teeth — real, enforceable consequences if someone crosses the line. That’s what you need when you realize Bob’s “little project” is cannibalizing your revenue.

The Bonus Mess: IP and Confidential Info

Even if Bob built his side hustle off the clock, what he’s using might still be yours.

If he took pricing sheets, client contact lists, design templates, or messaging you paid to develop, that’s no longer just moonlighting — it’s theft of intellectual property.

But again, if you don’t have a confidentiality policy or IP clause in place, proving that gets a whole lot harder. You’re now arguing over what’s “common knowledge” versus “company property,” and that’s a fight you don’t want to fund.

This Isn’t About Crushing Side Hustles

Let’s be clear: not every side project is a problem.

Lots of employees freelance, coach, or sell artisanal dog sweaters on weekends. If they’re doing it above board and it’s not stepping on your toes, no harm done.

The problem is when side hustles become shadow companies — and you end up training and funding your next competitor without knowing it.

You don’t need to ban creativity.

You just need boundaries.

RascalHR Conflict of Interest Policies Actually Hold Up

This is what Rascal is built for.

We write clear, enforceable conflict of interest policies tailored to your business and your province. Not legalese. Not overkill. Just real-world documents that make it easy to say: “That? That’s not okay. And here’s why.”

When Bob launches his business with your client list and your copy, you won’t have to panic-scroll through old emails hoping you have something on file.

You’ll have policies. You’ll have processes. And you’ll have protection.

Get your conflict of interest policy right →